Dual Extracted Tinctures vs. Hot Water Extractions
About
Dual Extraction Tinctures and Hot Water Extraction are two popular methods for extracting the medicinal benefits of mushrooms. While both techniques aim to capture the bioactive compounds present in mushrooms, they differ in their approach and the types of constituents they extract. Here's a comparison and contrast of these two extraction methods.
Dual Extrated Tinctures
Dual extraction involves using a combination of alcohol (we use 200 proof organic grain alcohol) and water to extract the medicinal compounds from mushrooms. This method takes advantage of the different solubilities of compounds in alcohol and water, allowing for a comprehensive extraction. The alcohol extracts non-polar compounds such as triterpenoids, while water extracts polar compounds such as beta-glucans. By combining both extractions, a dual extraction tincture offers a broader spectrum of mushroom constituents.
Advantages:
-
Comprehensive extraction: Dual extraction tinctures capture a wider range of bioactive compounds, including both alcohol-soluble and water-soluble constituents.
-
Enhanced potency: The use of alcohol helps extract certain compounds that may not be fully soluble in water, thus increasing the tincture's potency.
-
Longer shelf life: The alcohol in the tincture acts as a preservative, extending its shelf life.
Disadvantages:
-
Alcohol content: Some individuals may prefer to avoid alcohol due to personal or health reasons.
-
Potentially higher cost: The process of dual extraction requires the use of both alcohol and water, which may leads to a higher production cost.
Hot Water Extraction
Hot water extraction, also known as decoction, involves simmering mushrooms in water for an extended period to extract their medicinal properties. This method primarily targets water-soluble compounds, including beta-glucans, polysaccharides, and other heat-stable constituents. Hot water extraction is commonly used in traditional herbal preparations and is known for its simplicity and accessibility.
Advantages:
-
Accessible and simple: Hot water extraction can be easily done at home by adding the mushrooms to coffee, tea, soup bases, or simmered for longer periods of time to make a stronger extraction and then frozen into cubes for later use.
-
Water-soluble compounds: This method efficiently extracts water-soluble bioactive compounds, particularly beta-glucans, which are well-known for their immune-modulating properties.
-
Cost-effective: Hot water extraction requires minimal additional ingredients, making it a cost-effective method.
Disadvantages:
-
Limited extraction: Hot water extraction primarily targets water-soluble compounds, potentially missing out on certain alcohol-soluble constituents, such as triterpenoids.
-
Reduced potency: Some compounds may degrade or be less soluble in hot water, leading to a lower concentration of bioactive constituents in the final extract.
